Lawn Care Forum banner

Scotts TTTF vs Blue Tag

5.1K views 6 replies 6 participants last post by  M32075  
#1 ·
Location: Upstate SC 7b/8a
I spent a couple weeks researching seed cultivars from NC State and then trying to source them from my local suppliers for TTTF overseed. I have an established TTTF lawn that I seeded with Black Beauty last 2 years and I have not been as impressed with it and wanted to try something different. I have a print out of about 50 top NTEP seeds from NC State and just been looking at all the seed tags. I found a local nursery that had Top Choice (blue tag) TTTF 50lb bags for $135 ($2.70per/#).
Avenger II - 33% - Germ 90%
Raptor III - 33% - Germ 90%
Valkyrie LS - 33% - Germ 90%
Weed Seed - 0.00%

**UPDATED**Yesterday I was just curios at Home Depot and noticed they have Scotts Tall Fescue Mix 40lb bags for $75 ($3.75per/#). Reading over the label it was:
50% of the bag weight is seed coating, 40lb bag = 20lb of actual seed
Falcon IV - 16.8% - Germ 80%
Rhambler SRP - 16.8% - Germ 80%
Temple - 16.7% - Germ 80%
Weed Seed 0.10%

Previously, Scotts usually has 1 to 2 good seeds out of the 3 blended. But in the 2021 bags this year, they are all reputable cultivars. I am looking to seed around 80lbs of seed. I see the Top Choice has a 90% germ rate and Scotts is an 80%, so I would be losing 10% germination and 0.10% weed seed. I am planning on putting out Tenacity this week, then seeding in 25days with another Tenacity application.

I would like your opinion on paying 30%+ in price for +10% germination rate and -0.10% Weed Seed that will most likely be controlled with Tenacity?

**UPDATE** After learning that half the bag weight is "Seed Coating", the Scotts is a poor decision all around. Going with Top Choice
 
#4 ·
Its recommended to buy more seed than you need so if you're looking to seed 80lbs then the real math is two 50lb bags of better seed for $270 or three 40lb bags of lesser quality for $225.

That's a fairly high weed seed percentage especially when you consider how many seeds are in a bag and how much you are looking to seed.

It's not always the case but at the end of the day when it comes to seed you usually get what you pay for and when you consider the work involved most will usually opt for better quality to increase the chances of success and limit the amount of weeds to fight.
 
#5 ·
Update*** @stevehollx is 100% correct. I went back to Home Depot today cause it was killing me what the 3rd cultivar was and I was wrong on the %s. They are 16.7% each = 50%, the other 50% of the 20lbs is inert seed coating. SO you buy a 40lb bag, you are getting 20lbs of seed. Definitely a good marketing "gimmick". With knowing this, the Scotts seed is now $3.80 per lb, which is WAY more than the non-coated Top Choice.

Going to go with the Top Choice seed. READ THE FINE PRINT!!