Have you considered the benefits of a good, reliable goat? Based on your height of cut, I would recommend looking for a John Deere 200E off of auction. The 7 blade reel would be best for your needs. Sure it's heavy and there may be a little maintenance to refurbish, but you are already down this rabbit hole and your height is a perfect fit for a 220E. Go for it!

 

I'm going to recommend a 20" Tru Cut for your size lawn and description. Maybe a John Deere 180.

 

I fear that most of the powered reel mowers are going to be disappointment because they can be a little heavy/difficult and they do require some regular mechanical love compared to that push you're perfectly happy with.

POWER doesn't improve the quality of cut. It only makes the act of mowing less physically demanding.

There is nothing wrong with a good push reel mower. My GM1600 broke a bedbar and I mowed 7k at 1/2" with a push 7 blade and it looked as good except for the missing stripes. There was just a lot more sweating.

Push Reel Mowers
better = Mascot Silent Cut ($75 used)
best = Hudson Star Classic Cut Mower ($700 used, hard to find)

Electric Reel Mowers
Sun Joe, corded ~$160 new
Gardena, battery ~$500 new

'Golf course' mowers only needed to mower below 1"; There are a few 18" mowers if you must but they will not tolerate roots and sticks.
Toro Flex 18
Toro Greensmaster 800
John Deere 180*
etc

 

Getting a BETTER manual reel is actually a really tempting idea. Still get the quiet effect, and the workout, but better piece of equipment. Also, I have a 16 inch and an 18 inch would be nice I think. The 21 seems awkward and is harder to push from what I'm reading.

 

I fear that most of the powered reel mowers are going to be disappointment because they can be a little heavy/difficult and they do require some regular mechanical love compared to that push you're perfectly happy with.

POWER doesn't improve the quality of cut. It only makes the act of mowing less physically demanding.

There is nothing wrong with a good push reel mower. My GM1600 broke a bedbar and I mowed 7k at 1/2" with a push 7 blade and it looked as good except for the missing stripes. There was just a lot more sweating.

Push Reel Mowers
better = Mascot Silent Cut ($75 used)
best = Hudson Star Classic Cut Mower ($700 used, hard to find)

Electric Reel Mowers
Sun Joe, corded ~$160 new
Gardena, battery ~$500 new

'Golf course' mowers only needed to mower below 1"; There are a few 18" mowers if you must but they will not tolerate roots and sticks.
Toro Flex 18
Toro Greensmaster 800
John Deere 180*
etc

That Hudson star looks awesome. I was always curious about the Gardena. If Gardena or sun joe could redesign with a rear roller they could kill it.

 

here is a mascot silent cut i found in Merritt island look in good shape with grass catcher, if they take less could be worth the drive https://spacecoast.craigslist.org/for/d/merritt-island-mascot-18-silent-cut/6953598300.html

 

here is a mascot silent cut i found in Merritt island look in good shape with grass catcher, if they take less could be worth the drive https://spacecoast.craigslist.org/for/d/merritt-island-mascot-18-silent-cut/6953598300.html

Man that is tempting.....my parents actually live on Merritt Island, so the trip could be to visit them or they could pick it up and my Dad drives into Orlando every weekday and he could bring it to me.

I just hate to spend another $100 or so when I just bought this one less than 2 months ago. Not sure the difference would be worth it yet...would be a hard sell to the husband I think. I mean, he wouldn't get upset, he sort of lets me do whatever I want with the lawn stuff, but I'd feel a need to justify it, you know?

Is something like that significantly better that what I'm using, quality wise? It does have an easier way to adjust the height quickly which is nice, but would the big wheels instead of a roller bar like mine has mean more scalping I wonder? (not having issues with scalping yet anyway, but I do have those exposed roots, etc)

 

here is a mascot silent cut i found in Merritt island look in good shape with grass catcher, if they take less could be worth the drive https://spacecoast.craigslist.org/for/d/merritt-island-mascot-18-silent-cut/6953598300.html

Man that is tempting.....my parents actually live on Merritt Island, so the trip could be to visit them or they could pick it up and my Dad drives into Orlando every weekday and he could bring it to me.

I just hate to spend another $100 or so when I just bought this one less than 2 months ago. Not sure the difference would be worth it yet...would be a hard sell to the husband I think. I mean, he wouldn't get upset, he sort of lets me do whatever I want with the lawn stuff, but I'd feel a need to justify it, you know?

Is something like that significantly better that what I'm using, quality wise? It does have an easier way to adjust the height quickly which is nice, but would the big wheels instead of a roller bar like mine has mean more scalping I wonder? (not having issues with scalping yet anyway, but I do have those exposed roots, etc)

I have no idea on cut quality was just going on Oceanus recommendation a few posts up, I doubt it will be a huge step up and wouldn't go out of my way, since you have family close throw them a $50 offer, you can compare it and sell the one you don't like.

Only link i can find selling it $369 don't know it comes with grass catcher looks to have a rear roller also https://www.lehmans.com/product/mascot-silent-cut-reel-mowers/

 

You know, I think I will just use what I have to finish out the season. It cut really well today after my husband adjusted the reel/bed knife distance last night. And the lighter weight makes it easy for me to pick up and move, etc. Doubling the weight is not appealing, although the ease of height adjustment certainly is. But I pick it up more than I adjust the height, so I'll wait and see how things go. That seems saner, right?

 

Besides, I want to save up for rotary scissors/landscape blade, lol. But for next season, that heavier duty manual reel might be the answer.

 

I don't know what your budget is, but as a 5'3" 105 lb woman, I can relate to a lot of what you said about what you want in a mower. I was the same way. I started out with a manual because I was a bit intimidated with the noise and power of a gas mower. I really liked the quietness of the manual. Unfortunately, it just wasn't sustainable to mow that often in the heat and also the grass was washboarding like crazy. I got a used CalTrimmer with some encouragement from the guys on here. My husband showed me how to use it and it was manageable. There were things I didn't care for about it like how it sometimes dug into the grass if it was too wet and the grass catcher was fairly heavy for me. Overall though, good mower. My issue with the CalTrimmer came with the fact that it felt unsafe to me with the spinning blades everywhere on the slope in my front yard. I also have young kids and I can't have them out there while I mow because to me it feels unsafe. I know plenty of people mow around their kids but I don't like the noise, I can't hear them, and I have to constantly watch that they don't run in front of the mower especially if I mow without the grass catcher.

I just bought a Swardman Electra. It was a crazy amount of money which if you would have asked me two years ago if I ever would have spent that kind of money on a yard tool, I would have laughed. To me, it's the best of both worlds. It has the power of the gas engine but it's quiet and I feel it's pretty safe given that if I let go of the handle the blade stops immediately. It's much lighter weight but gives a cut similar to a greensmower (from what I've heard, I don't have a greensmower). It's not perfect. I mowed my front yard with the slopes last night and found that it has a tendency to drift on a slope because of the drum in the back. Because it's not my old beater mower, I realized how rough I am manhandling the mower around and now I'm trying to be more careful. Example: I let the trimmer kind of skid along the crevice next to the sidewalk because who cares, it's 30 years old and scratched up. I care now that my new mower is so pretty. Some of this is just getting adjusted to a new mower which is why I haven't done a full review and posted it. But, you said you have a flat yard. With a flat yard (like i have in the back) it's like just walking around your yard pushing a stroller or shopping cart or something. It's a lot more like manual mowing than gas mowing.

The Electra weighs 130lbs (I think) which is much easier for me to handle. The trimmer with the reel roller was close to 180 lbs (I have the old iron block engine which my husband assures me makes it heavier than the newer ones but I can't say for sure). The mower felt too big for me which I didn't like but the trimmer was a huge step up from a manual and if there had not been an electric reel option, I would have kept mowing with it. If you want to step it up to the next level, I would get a used one of those. If your yard is fairly flat, you won't feel like it's too much for you as long as you aren't mowing on slopes. I never minded mowing the back yard. I would suggest getting a higher blade count than the 5 they often have so you can mow lower and avoid the washboarding.

I was in the same spot you are now wondering if I should spend $300 and get a mascot or a nicer manual but I'm glad I went with the gas. Of course, my husband does all the maintenance on it because I have no idea what I'm doing. It's been good though. The lawn has kinda become our thing. We each have our part that we do despite the fact that he at one point told me he would never take care of a yard. I knew it would suck him in eventually just like it did me.

 

You got me, my dream is the Swardman Electra. For all the reasons you mentioned, including being able to hear the kids if they yell for me. But, not happening right now. However, maybe next year's bonus when my husband gets it...and if I wait another year or two maybe there will be some used ones on the market

 

Wanted to clarify that I still want recommendations, even though I'm not ready to grab something today. Want to think more before making an impulse buy, if that make sense.

I also saw in another thread that someone called the local country clubs/golf courses to ask about used mowers for sale. That never occurred to me! Not many home owners reel mow here, but Florida has a metric crap ton of golf courses!

 

The easiest mower for me to deal with has been a Toro GM 1000. Yes, a greensmower. To put it in perspective, I am 5'6" and 135 lbs on a good day. A guy but the size of a woman. The GM moves under its own power no pushing or pulling. It is also rather maneuverable even in the small lawns I normally deal with. Turning it is not a problem. Put it in neutral, push down slightly on the handlebar and pivot it on the split rear roller.

 

The easiest mower for me to deal with has been a Toro GM 1000. Yes, a greensmower. To put it in perspective, I am 5'6" and 135 lbs on a good day. A guy but the size of a woman. The GM moves under its own power no pushing or pulling. It is also rather maneuverable even in the small lawns I normally deal with. Turning it is not a problem. Put it in neutral, push down slightly on the handlebar and pivot it on the split rear roller.

Good info, thank you!

 

FYI, there are multiple versions of the Mascot, that one is for 'Upright Grasses' (noted by larger wheels). I found a 'bentgrass' version on Facebook for $50, but it's sold now. link

Best info for Mascot is normally here currently down, so try the wayback link

I wouldn't kick the Swardman Electra out of my yard, but I've personally just purchased a GM1000 (21"). I like how simple and common the GM1000s are, which should make it easier to service as a home owner. My GM1600 (26") seemed a little too big for the yard but it was easy to handle after a little practice. However, I didn't recommend these because of your "harder to break/ruin" requirement. I bent the bedknife on the grass-curb transition (that I've mowed a dozen times before) and that stopped the mower cold. So, they are easy to break, hard/expensive to fix.

I didn't notice you're in Orlando. I generally don't see many decent mowers nearby. More towards Tampa, Fort Myers, and Vero. Best listing locally is a JD link.

 

That Hudson star looks awesome. I was always curious about the Gardena. If Gardena or sun joe could redesign with a rear roller they could kill it.

There's one South of San Antonio now

If I ever find one like that in Florida or willing to ship... I'm gonna have to try it.

 

I'm another central Floridian, only on the east coast. I used, and still have a McLane 20" 7 blade reel mower that was my primary machine, but I took the plunge last November, during the Black Friday sales, and purchased the Swardman Edwin 55, with the 10 blade reel and all the other cartridges. I figured it would probably outlast me, so why not. I'm very happy with the Swardman as far as how it cuts, the striping, and ease of maneuvering. My only issue with it, is along my palms in the front, where the lawn is raised up around the trunks, the mower wants to slide a little. I've figured out a trick, so it's not a big deal.

 

No love for the Fiskars Staysharp? (For a manual, of course -- it can't hang with the powered ones.) The Scotts and other brands of lightweight manual push mowers feel cheap and junky compared to it, yet it's still not that expensive. I see them on Craigslist all the time for under $100, and often they're barely used as people find they don't want to put forth the effort. But mine is super easy to push. I've mowed my approx 8k sq ft with one many times.

Also, since I'm here, has anyone compared these to the Mascot/Agrifab type mowers? I know where I can get a Mascot pretty cheap (if the guy still has it) but I thought the Fiskars mechanics of a chain-driven reel would probably be superior to having the reel attached to the wheels axle.

 

I have a Fiskars stay sharp. It was a great entry level reel mower but it washboards like crazy once your grass gets thick and without majorly altering the mower, you can't get lower than 1".

 

I've heard the Earthwise 7 blade I have gets a better cut on Bermuda than the Fiskars 5 blade does. And the earhtwise has a roller in the back instead of just wheels, so better on uneven ground as far as preventing scalping.

 

I have a Fiskars stay sharp. It was a great entry level reel mower but it washboards like crazy once your grass gets thick and without majorly altering the mower, you can't get lower than 1".

When you posted this a couple of weeks ago I didn't know what you meant by washboarding. Well, just the other day I started seeing it for the first time. Guess my new lawn finally got thick enough.

Does this happen with the Earthwise or with a Mascot? Is it simply a matter of the number of blades? I like the idea of a manual mower and don't mind the effort and frequency of mowing if it will work.

 

@Chocolate Lab It's about the number of blades and how fast/slow the blades are moving. @Ware has a document about this that he posts from time to time. I switched to a CalTrimmer with the same number of blades and the washboard went away until I started mowing lower and the grass got even thicker.

I'm sure that more blades on a manual mower would be better but I don't know if it can compete with a gas (or Swardman electric) quality of cut. I've never tried the Mascot but that was my next consideration until I was unexpectedly given the CalTrimmer by my grandfather-in-law.
For what you could spend on a Mascot, unless you could get it used, is what you could get a used gas powered reel for. I've heard good things about the Earthwise but I think the mascots are heavier which may be to your advantage.

 

I'm sure that more blades on a manual mower would be better but I don't know if it can compete with a gas (or Swardman electric) quality of cut. I've never tried the Mascot but that was my next consideration until I was unexpectedly given the CalTrimmer by my grandfather-in-law.
For what you could spend on a Mascot, unless you could get it used, is what you could get a used gas powered reel for. I've heard good things about the Earthwise but I think the mascots are heavier which may be to your advantage.

Thanks... Yes, I do think I'll eventually get a gas-powered one. In fact, there's a decent-looking McClane at a good price close to me right now and a fairly priced Tru-cut in a city I often travel to.

But my garage is really cramped right now and I do love hanging the manual reel on the wall, plus the quiet of a manual reel. Still thinking about trying the Mascot if it's really still available.

 

I'm sure that more blades on a manual mower would be better but I don't know if it can compete with a gas (or Swardman electric) quality of cut. I've never tried the Mascot but that was my next consideration until I was unexpectedly given the CalTrimmer by my grandfather-in-law.
For what you could spend on a Mascot, unless you could get it used, is what you could get a used gas powered reel for. I've heard good things about the Earthwise but I think the mascots are heavier which may be to your advantage.

Thanks... Yes, I do think I'll eventually get a gas-powered one. In fact, there's a decent-looking McClane at a good price close to me right now and a fairly priced Tru-cut in a city I often travel to.

But my garage is really cramped right now and I do love hanging the manual reel on the wall, plus the quiet of a manual reel. Still thinking about trying the Mascot if it's really still available.

If you do get the mascot, I'd love to see a review of it. Even though I have the Swardman, part of me still would like to try a nice manual and see how it is. There are some frustrating hills on a part of my yard that a smooth drum is not the best for. I don't think my husband would be supportive of me getting ANOTHER mower.